Interesting personnel situation with two former Giants tight ends going in the Vikings-Saints NFC Championship game this weekend. Jeremy Shockey has had a quietly productive year for the Saints with 48 catches for 569 yards and three touchdowns, and Visanthe Shiancoe (56 catches, 566 yards, 11 TDs) has had an outstanding season with the Vikes.
Meanwhile, the Giants' Kevin Boss proved himself tough and smart, but was grossly under-used as a receiver for a variety of reason, most notably because he was needed to block in the many max protect schemes.
So here's the question. Given their relative impact on their respective teams, who would you want to see on the Giants? Is Boss sufficient. Should the Giants have continued to put up with Shockey? Should Shiancoe never have been set loose in free agency? You tell me.
New York Giants news, 10/24: A plan for fixing the Giants
21 minutes ago